Evangelical Philosophical SocietyArticle Reprint

Intrinsic and Extrinsic Teleology: Their Irrelevance to Aquinas's Fifth Way and to Paley's Argument from Design

by Marie George

Edward Feser (along with many other Thomists) maintains that the distinction between having an intrinsic tendency to an end as opposed to a tendency to an end imposed from without is crucial to understanding Aquinas’s Fifth Way. (Feser calls the former “immanent teleology” and the latter “extrinsic teleology").

In this essay, Marie George argues that this position is incorrect by examining the two syllogisms that compose the Fifth Way.  She then briefly considers whether “extrinsic teleology” is essential to Paley’s argument from design, by examining this argument stated in its strongest form.  The article concludes that it is counterproductive to read “extrinsic teleology” into what would otherwise be an argument for God’s existence worthy of further consideration.

The full-text of this paper is available for FREE by clicking here.

©2020 Evangelical Philosophical Society. All rights Reserved.  

This article is made public for personal, non-commercial use only.  You must obtain prior written permission for any other use.  The Evangelical Philosophical Society  (EPS) is an organization of professional scholars devoted to pursuing philosophical excellence in both the church and the academy. Interested laypersons can join as full, associate, or student members.  The EPS journal, Philosophia Christi, is a scholarly publication containing discussion of a variety of topics that are of interest to the philosopher and to the philosopher of religion.

For membership information, please visit www.epsociety.org or you may contact us by phone or e-mail.